Ask Levittown Roofing Expert: Metal Roofing Vs. Asphalt Shingles. Pros, Cons, and Comparison

Ask Levittown Roofing Expert: Metal Roofing Vs. Asphalt Shingles. Pros, Cons, and Comparison

Metal Roof vs Asphalt Shingles

You need more than for your house to be safe when you are planning where you will live, and the rooftop is a major factor in sheltering and securing home. A rooftop fits the basic structure, shields you from external elements, and protects you from the summer’s warmth and winter’s cold. Below we will talk about the most popular material options: metal rooftops and asphalt shingles, with the goal that you can choose which is better for you.


Metal materials are available in an assortment of styles. These are to a great extent reliant on the metal and coatings utilized. Aluminum is a metal that needs no covering. Steel, however, requires particular treatment to counteract rust. Other metals utilized as material in the construction are copper, zinc, treated steel, and titanium.

Asphalt shingles come in two assortments, the more up to date fiberglass shingles and customary natural ones. The thing that matters is in their layered make-up. Fiberglass shingles have a fiberglass center secured with an asphalt layer. Natural shingles have an overwhelming felt layer under the asphalt.


The layered look of black-top shingles is by a wide margin the more prominent of the two sorts. By far, many of roofing in Levittown, PA have black-top shingles, to a great extent since asphalt is the material most developers trust and what mortgage holders are acquainted with seeing on houses. Black-top shingles can differ in hues to coordinate the paint or block of a home, and the assortment of their hues is more than with metal material. The three-tab shingles give a level appearance while the more costly structural shingles seem progressively three dimensional.

Metal rooftops are once in a while observed in urban and rural zones. The smooth, metallic appearance appears to be more suited for a farming setting. Metal materials come in an assortment of hues and styles to coordinate with the rest of the home. The metal can be in boards, tiles, or shingles, yet the appearance of a metal rooftop still can be bumping in an area loaded with black-top shingles.


Installing black-top shingles is simpler to do than introducing a metal rooftop; however, because of the heaviness of shingles, particularly modern ones, prior shingle materials must be removed first. Likewise, guarantee and protection necessities may request the evacuation of past black-top shingles. A material square of three-tab shingles, which is 100 square feet, can gauge 200 pounds, and a square of structural shingles can weigh as much as 500 pounds. Since the establishment is simpler, even with removing a past rooftop, introducing black-top shingles can take anywhere from two days to a week, contingent upon the size of the house.

Some metal material, then again, is a lot lighter and can be introduced over the existing rooftop. The weight differs depending on the material utilized. Aluminum weighs just around 50 pounds for every square while steel weighs 100 to 250 pounds. One motivation behind why material with metal makes longer is the additional stride of laying compressed wood or situated strand board (OSB) under the metal. This added step helps in dampening the noise associated with metal. With the proper installation, rainfall or even hail should sound the same inside a home with a metal rooftop as it does inside a home with black-top shingles.

Installation of these roofing materials should be done by professionals only. It is quite dangerous to work on a roof, and installing roofing materials is a demanding activity. Areas around vents must be appropriately managed, and blazing 5 must be deliberately established. Additionally, if the materials are not expertly installed, then the warranty of the manufacturer can be considered void.


Metal material will cost roughly $250 to $600 per material square or $2 to $6 per square foot for steel or aluminum shingles, $120 to $150 for corrugated steel boards, and $700 to $900 for copper or zinc. In terms of installation, a steel or aluminum rooftop will cost about $500 to $1,000 per square. For a home with a 1,500-square-foot rooftop, this comes to about $7,500 to $15,000. For a home with a 2,500-square-foot rooftop, this comes to $12,500 to $25,000. This is, overall, multiple times the expense of black-top shingles and is one of the reasons why homeowners choose asphalt shingles.

Energy Efficiency

A metal rooftop will bring down your energy bills by around 40 percent. The intelligent surface diminishes the exchange of warmth into the home. Then again, black-top shingles ingest the sun’s warmth, moving it through the rooftop to the home, making the home’s cooling system work harder. This is the reason why black-top shingles are suggested primarily for mild climates.

In winter, black-top shingles perform better, utilizing the warmth from the winter daylight to make the home a lot hotter. Be that as it may, metal rooftops likewise perform well in winter. The overall energy use will, in any case, be lower with metal than with asphalt.

All things considered, some black-top shingle styles are assigned as cool roofs and join some metal rooftops in conveying an Energy Star rating for higher energy effectiveness. These roofing materials are ensured to reflect a greater amount of the sun’s heat, bringing down the rooftop’s temperature by up to 50 degrees Fahrenheit. Even though different variables can influence the energy savings, the different materials can reduce the temperature in the home at peak times by 10 to 15 percent.

To balance the expense of installing another rooftop, you can search for Energy Star affirmed asphalt shingles or metal rooftops. When utilizing these energy efficient materials, 10 percent of the materials cost, up to $500, can be acquired as an energy credit.


The higher expense of metal material is counterbalanced by its long life. A metal rooftop can keep going for a long time with little maintenance. Most material producers offer a 50-year guarantee on metal rooftops. Nonetheless, a black-top rooftop should be supplanted a few times during that equivalent 60-year term. Guarantees for asphalt shingles change from 20 to 25 years.

Asphalt shingles are defenseless to hail and high wind harm, even though fiberglass shingles are tougher than natural ones. Likewise, if asphalt shingles don’t get satisfactory daylight, they can collect the form, green growth, or mold. Metal rooftops, then again, are prevalent entertainers in high breezes and bad climate, and they are impenetrable to mold and bugs. Metal rooftops perform so well under cruel conditions that owners in more than 25 states are qualified for protection limits when they introduce weather and heatproof metal rooftops.

On the off chance that the metal rooftop is low-quality steel without a satisfactory rust proof covering, then use near saltwater isn’t advised. Progressively costly, rustproof metal and coatings ought to be utilized.

Imperviousness to fire

A few maker’s asphalt shingle lines are appraised Class A for flame security, particularly the fiberglass varieties. Additionally, all-metal rooftops are heatproof, steel, and copper more so than aluminum. This settles on metal material a decent decision in zones prone to wildfire.


Metal rooftops win the day concerning reuse issues. Some are made with reused materials, and all are recyclable. Around 1 million tons of asphalt shingles are discarded every year, and they can be recycled into an assortment of items. The expense to reuse them is commonly not exactly to put them in landfills. Be that as it may, accessible recyclers for asphalt shingles are not many; however, the improvement of all the more reusing accessibility is in progress.


With metal material repairs are much harder since a large portion of the metal utilized is made in sheets and should be replaced in that way. So when there is a problem to address, then black-top is simpler and more affordable to fix or replace. Metal rooftops require little maintenance and should be fixed far less of the time.

Resale Value

Since a metal rooftop is solid, sturdy, and energy efficient, it should increase a home’s value. By certain estimates, the resale worth will increase by 1 to 6 percent over a house with black-top shingles. However, the purchaser must like the appearance of a metal rooftop. Any new rooftop will help sell a home since purchasers need to have a sense of safety about the state of the rooftop over their heads.

Latest News


More Articles Like This

- Advertisement -spot_img